[Samba] BIND as DNS Slave of SAMBA 4 Internal DNS and Windows 2008

[bentunx]

hi guys

i need some advice for my case that i faced here..

i have Two AD with two different domain, platform and network :

i expect all user in different domain can resolve the other domain dns


let say
1. domainwin.com >> windows 2008 AD >> 172.16.1.2

2. domainnux.com >> Samba 4 AD >> 172.16.2.2

is it possible if i create 1 new BIND DNS Server in 172.16.3.2
(different network) that work as slave DNS of domainwin.com/172.16.1.2
and domainnuxcom/172.16.2.2 then i make new DNS BIND SERVER
(172.16.3.2) as DNS forwarder in AD domainwin.com and AD domainnux.com ?


TIA

Zhia Chandra

[bentunx]

hi all


after i browsing around i found this

/Managing zone transfers is not implemented yet. //Bug report #9951:DNS
MMC: Enabling DNS zone transfers in MMC fails
<https://bugzilla.samba.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9951>/

is this bug aready resolve in samba 4.1 or earlier ?
btw im using samba 4.4.4 in domainnux.com AD

Post by bentunx
hi guys
i need some advice for my case that i faced here..
i expect all user in different domain can resolve the other domain dns
let say
1. domainwin.com >> windows 2008 AD >> 172.16.1.2
2. domainnux.com >> Samba 4 AD >> 172.16.2.2
is it possible if i create 1 new BIND DNS Server in 172.16.3.2
(different network) that work as slave DNS of domainwin.com/172.16.1.2
and domainnuxcom/172.16.2.2 then i make new DNS BIND SERVER
(172.16.3.2) as DNS forwarder in AD domainwin.com and AD domainnux.com ?
TIA
Zhia Chandra

[Stefan Kania]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

you should set up a dns-proxy and use this proxy as forwarder in your
domains

Post by bentunx
hi guys
i need some advice for my case that i faced here..
i expect all user in different domain can resolve the other domain dns
let say 1. domainwin.com >> windows 2008 AD >> 172.16.1.2
2. domainnux.com >> Samba 4 AD >> 172.16.2.2
is it possible if i create 1 new BIND DNS Server in 172.16.3.2
(different network) that work as slave DNS of
domainwin.com/172.16.1.2 and domainnuxcom/172.16.2.2 then i make
new DNS BIND SERVER (172.16.3.2) as DNS forwarder in AD
domainwin.com and AD domainnux.com ?
TIA
Zhia Chandra

- --
Stefan Kania


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (GNU/Linux)

iEYEARECAAYFAleoVbcACgkQ2JOGcNAHDTYmwQCgzQ4vIEF1TyZRhnEdBd+5vlFI
sVIAn0stMmE2rPpNQPsDIoPNlZl+uIGZ
=Q2cS
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

[Nico Kadel-Garcia]

This post might be inappropriate. Click to display it.